September 8, 2023 Outlook: Lee’s exceptionally rapid intensification makes it a category 5 in the open Atlantic

One-sentence summary

Hurricane Lee has rapidly intensified into a powerful category 5 storm, and while it will not threaten land for at least a week or so, it will stir up rough surf and rip currents from the Caribbean to the East Coast of the U.S. in coming days.

One-image summary

Hurricane Lee around sunset on Thursday as it was in the middle of its rapid intensification to category 5 intensity. (Colorado State University)

Hurricane Lee: 165 mph, moving WNW 14 mph

What’s changed since yesterday?

Lee went from an 80 mph storm yesterday to a 165 one today, an extraordinary rate of intensification that places it on the leaderboard in recent years. Lee is on the cusp of being one of the strongest Atlantic hurricanes on record.

Lee continues west-northwest, and while models continue to agree on an eventual northward turn, the timing, speed, and location of that turn will be important in determining the next steps next week.

Lee is expected to maintain its current trajectory through the weekend with a gradual decrease in forward speed. (Tomer Burg)

Lee’s impacts through the weekend

Lee will not directly impact any land mass over the next few days. But it will make itself known. Large swells generated from Lee are expected in the northern Caribbean, including Puerto Rico and eventually Hispaniola, the Turks and Caicos Islands, and the Bahamas. Rough surf and very strong rip currents are expected, so if you live in these areas or are planning to swim in these areas this weekend or next week, please be very, very cautious.

Swells will build and begin to impact the U.S. East Coast, Bermuda, and eventually the Canadian Maritimes, probably building from south to north beginning around Sunday. Much of next week will feature rough surf and strong rip currents on the Eastern Seaboard.

Lee’s intensity forecast

We should be seeing peak Lee today. Normally, category 5 storms do not stay there. They become vulnerable to internal and some external forces that can cause them to fluctuate in intensity, sometimes considerably. Lee could Sisyphus its way along the intensity scale tonight through Sunday.

Beyond that, Lee is likely to drop back a notch, probably fluctuating between category 2 and 4 intensity next week as it turns the corner off the East Coast. Certainly still a powerful storm but not quite peak intensity. As Lee further gains latitude later next week, it should weaken further, but in compensation, it could expand in size or increase its forward speed some. Its impacts would still not be that of a category 5 in terms of wind, but it will be capable of causing problems should it make it to land or close to land.

Lee’s track forecast

We have little clarity on Lee’s track next week, except to say that it still is likely to miss to the east of Florida, Georgia, and South Carolina. As Lee advances forward, it will slow down. When Lee gets to a point somewhere just northeast of the Turks & Caicos Islands or southeast Bahamas, we will see it possibly slow to a crawl. This should occur Monday and Tuesday.

Lee is going to slam on the brakes just northeast of the Turks and Caicos Islands. The shift in color from red to yellow/green indicates the high uncertainty in exactly where Lee turns north. Forecast confidence plunges at that point right now with a wide berth of options ranging from just off the East Coast to out to sea. (Tomer Burg)

Lee will then turn hard to the north. Beyond that point, Lee will be fighting a battle with a trough (dip in the jet stream) over the Eastern U.S., high pressure to Lee’s east, likely-Hurricane Margot, and a fairly substantial area of high pressure that establishes over Newfoundland. You can see those features on the map below. Again, the placement and intensity of these features will determine if Lee goes toward New England, toward Nova Scotia, out to sea, or out to sea and toward Bermuda. But it is clear that any direct land impacts would probably not occur until the end of next week or even next weekend.

Lee will be directed by the exact placement of an East Coast trough, high pressure north of Bermuda into Newfoundland, and Margot’s location. Nailing the forecast of all of these is imperative to figuring out where Lee goes. (Tropical Tidbits)

I’m curious about two things today. First, the ridge north of Bermuda extending up to Newfoundland may be a key to all this. It’s going to essentially narrow the escape route. If that were not there, we’d likely see Lee get picked up and ushered out to sea, no problem. With that exit door now cracked instead of wide open, I just get the sense that this is not going to exit easily.

Second, how will Margot and Lee interact? Last night’s operational European operational model showed an interesting scenario where the two systems come close to interacting with the Fujiwhara effect. In that scenario, Lee could theoretically be forced to go a bit to the east and Margot a bit to the west. There is a trivial but not impossible scenario where Lee gets directed away from land or a specific land point because of this.

More importantly, all of this underscores just how difficult predicting Lee’s end game will be for another few days at least. It’s a good time to review your hurricane plans if you live along the Mid-Atlantic or New England Coasts or in Canada to be safe, but we have a long, long way to go here.

We will keep you posted each day this weekend on forecast developments.

Margot makes a splash

Tropical Storm Margot formed yesterday in the far eastern Atlantic. It will not be a threat to land over the next week.

Tropical Storm Margot is expected to become a hurricane next week over the open Atlantic. (NOAA NHC)

Margot is expected to become a hurricane, another feather in the cap of those who predicted an active season this year. As noted above, we’ll watch to see if it can’t have influence on Lee’s eventual track outcome late next week.

Anything else?

Nope. The basin, at this point looks as though it should quiet down a bit outside of Lee and Margot. No new systems are expected for most of next week, although some recent GFS and Euro ensemble runs are trying to spin up another Cape Verde system late in the week. Nothing else we need to fret over right now, however.

September 7, 2023 Outlook: Lee loading up for a big show northeast of the Leeward Islands and Puerto Rico

One-sentence summary

Hurricane Lee is intensifying east of the Caribbean Islands, and it will likely become a category 4 or 5 storm this weekend before tracking northeast of the Bahamas and slowing down some, increasing uncertainty as to where it will ultimately track next week.

Hurricane Lee is expected to become a major hurricane by tomorrow and a category 4 or 5 storm this weekend. (Tomer Burg)

Hurricane Lee: 80 mph, moving WNW 13 mph

What’s changed since Wednesday?

Lee is now a hurricane and likely beginning its rapid intensification process. The forecast track remains highly uncertain beyond the weekend.

Hurricane Lee is organizing into a robust storm east of the Leeward Islands and should continue to steadily intensify today. (Colorado State Univ)

Lee’s intensity outlook

Hurricane Lee should be in an environment conducive to steady, if not rapid intensification over the next couple days. We’re likely to see this become a category 4, if not a category 5 storm. Once it gets there, it will hold, with some fluctuations for a few days. Storms that achieve category 5 intensity usually do not stay there for more than a day or so, as the storm becomes vulnerable to eyewall replacement cycles which weaken winds but expand the radius of strong winds. Other factors like shear and forward speed can impact storms more when they reach top-end intensity. It is going to remain a powerful hurricane for awhile, but its peak intensity may be (relatively) brief.

Once Lee comes farther west and begins to turn more northward, it will likely encounter more unstable water temperatures as well. It could be dealing with remnant cooler water churned up by Hurricanes Franklin and Idalia. It may also slow down for a time to a point where it churns up cooler water itself that could lead to some “self-destructive behavior” (insert your own jokes here). Just to be clear, I’m not trying to downplay it, quite the contrary. Folks should know that you are going to observe these fluctuations in intensity, and that is absolutely normal, expected behavior for powerful hurricanes that should not lead to dismissing it as a “bust” or to qualify it as “weaker.” Despite lower top-end wind speed, the storm will probably grow in physical size some as it figures out where it’s going next week.

Lee’s track

I really can’t emphasize enough that there are so many factors that will dictate Lee’s ultimate track. Each one of these factors will matter daily next week. Imagine trying to forecast for five completely disparate locations 6 to 7 days in advance and nailing every aspect of that forecast perfectly. You probably can’t. I’ve done this for almost 20 years now, and I know I can’t. Because to unlock the key to Lee’s end game, you have to basically do just that.

The upper air map on Monday night should show Lee slowing a good bit north of the islands before eventually resuming a north-northwest or northerly track. Exactly where & when that happens will help determine Lee’s end game. (Tropical Tidbits)

So the map above shows you what’s happening around 20,000 feet up on Monday night. Lee at this point is north of the Caribbean islands and east of the Turks and Caicos Islands. High pressure to the north of Lee should weaken enough to allow Lee to barge through and start coming northwest or north. Additionally, Invest 96L may play some role (the “L” on the map above) in determining the orientation of things to the east of Lee. One of the big issues will be exactly what things look like when that turn happens. Where does that happen and when does that happen, and what will the trough (blue area) over the Great Lakes look like when that occurs. Because ultimately, that trough is going to have a say in Lee’s trajectory, and that could determine if Lee tracks close enough to the East Coast to cause impacts. Additionally, high pressure over Atlantic Canada (which has strengthened some in forecasts since yesterday) may also play a key role. In other words, we’re still at a loss as to Lee’s future simply because there are too many players out there trying to influence Lee’s movement and trying to precisely place them 5 to 7 days out is difficult. That placement matters a lot.

So, folks on the East Coast should continue to monitor Lee. Bermuda and the Canadian Maritime provinces should continue to monitor Lee. And, yes, the Turks and Caicos and Bahamas should as well. This is a tricky, delicately balanced situation and hopefully some consensus will emerge in the coming days.

Elsewhere

As noted above, Invest 96L is still out there and going to make a go for development into the weekend. It will not threaten land, but it will be part of Lee’s answer key. The next name on the list is Margot. Besides that, I don’t see much else over the next week or so of note.

Pacific Hurricane Jova

Quick note because I have a minute. Here is Hurricane Jova.

Jova is a beastly storm thankfully in the open waters of the East Pacific. It will not threaten the U.S. or Mexico. But I point it out because it has 160 mph winds and is a category 5 storm after rapidly, furiously intensifying. Storms this large can influence some things around it, so there’s probably some inherent forecast uncertainty to the west of Lee thanks in part to this storm. Aside from that, category five storms are a heck of a thing to observe in real-time. Glad it’s over the open ocean.

September 6, 2023 Outlook: Lee plodding west-northwest and strengthening; where will it ultimately go?

One-sentence summary

While Tropical Storm Lee’s ultimate future is unknown, it is likely to become a hurricane today, and it is still forecast to miss to the north of the islands with some modest fringe impacts there.

Tropical Storm Lee: 65 mph, moving WNW 14 mph

Lee is forecast to become a hurricane today and a major hurricane tomorrow and is still expected to go north of the Caribbean islands. (NOAA/Tomer Burg)

What’s changed since yesterday?

Invest 95L became Tropical Depression 13 briefly, and then it became Tropical Storm Lee yesterday afternoon. It is organizing and tracking west-northwest. Confidence that it will miss a direct impact on the islands is increasing. Confidence on anything beyond there is low.

Lee’s intensity

Lee is in a tremendously ideal environment for intensification. It has deep warm water, low shear, and plenty of moist air in the neighborhood for the next 5 or 6 days. Models have suggested since last week that this would go to the moon intensity-wise, and there’s no reason to doubt that today. The NHC forecast for Lee was one of its most aggressive on record, taking it to a category 4 storm by Sunday or Monday, something they will not commit to without confidence.

Lee is developing nice outflow and maintains a solid core. It will likely take on a “classic” hurricane look in a couple days. (Weathernerds.org)

Once Lee manages category 4 or 5 intensity by Friday or Saturday, it will likely fluctuate in intensity up and down for a few days, probably remaining a major, if not Cat 4-5 storm much of the time. Heading into next week, the question will become where Lee tracks relative to the cold wake in the Atlantic from upwelled water left behind by Hurricanes Franklin and Idalia.

There is much cooler water southwest of Bermuda that could impact Lee’s intensity next week as it comes northward. (Tropical Tidbits)

So, for now, expect a pretty impressive hurricane into early next week, followed up by some potential significant fluctuations in intensity as it comes northwest.

So where is Lee headed?

We have about 5 hurdles with respect to Lee’s track over the next 10 days or so. First, Puerto Rico and the Leeward Islands. Second, the Turks and Caicos and southeast Bahamas. Third, Bermuda. Fourth, the US coast, and lastly the Canadian Maritimes.

First, with respect to Puerto Rico and the islands, Lee is expected to pass to the north, comfortably enough to avoid significant impacts but definitely close enough to keep watch and expect fringe impacts (a few outer bands with gusty winds, rough surf, rip currents, etc.). So if you’re in Puerto Rico or the Virgin Islands, stay tuned and keep watch, but you are almost at the point of being able to exhale.

Beyond that, it remains to be seen what happens. Lee will be steered around the periphery of high pressure over the Atlantic. This should ensure it gets to a point northeast of the Bahamas early next week. From there, the players on the field become more difficult to assess. How strong is the high? Does it collapse, weakening steering currents? If it doesn’t collapse, where is it centered? Will the trough over the Great Lakes be strong enough to try to “capture” Lee and draw it more toward the East Coast? If Lee splits the gap between Bermuda and the Carolinas, will New England or the Maritimes be in the way on its way out? Will Lee be strong enough to just barge north toward Bermuda anyway? How much of a role will the cooler water out there play in Lee’s intensity? The map below shows the situation on Sunday evening.

Sunday evening’s upper air map shows high pressure near Bermuda which should keep Lee going northwest or west-northwest. After Monday, however, the steering currents may slow Lee down, making it susceptible to a lot of possible outcomes. (Tropical Tidbits)

There will be some people out there speaking with conviction about the future of Lee, and if so, you can tune them right out. Every question I just rhetorically asked has no answer yet. None. I personally think Lee will split the gap between Bermuda and the Carolinas and then hook out to sea, but I see a path where the trough digging in from the Lakes could try to draw it back west, especially if it’s weakened some by the cooler water west of Bermuda. I see how it could hit Bermuda directly or pass very close. I see a path where it misses Bermuda and the US but runs into Atlantic Canada. What I don’t have is confidence in any of those outcomes right now. There are too many “known unknowns” for confidence. I realize this answer won’t generate a lot of excitement, but this is exactly why we’re here…to provide sober, steady analysis of significant storms. Welcome to The Eyewall!

Anyway, let’s keep tabs on this over the next few days, and we’ll monitor the progress of the features that will steer Lee in the future. One thing I can say with confidence? Expect more rough surf and rip currents on the East Coast next week.

Beyond Lee

We recycled into Invest 96L yesterday, which is a very robust tropical wave just off the coast of Africa. That has a decent chance to become either Tropical Depression 14 or Tropical Storm Margot in the coming days. It is unlikely to threaten land other than some initial heavy rainfall in the Cabo Verde Islands.

Invest 96L may nudge across the Cabo Verde Islands before it develops, slowly, over the weekend into next week out at sea. (Tomer Burg)

After we get past 96L, there is a minimal chance of additional development in the Atlantic next week. The Gulf looks closed off, as does the western Caribbean, loaded with shear. The overall background state of the basin should be hostile to tropical development into next week. We may flip back to a more lively pattern again in the final 10 days of the month. We’ll see!

Taking stock of the 2023 Atlantic hurricane season so far: Active with headwinds; more to come?

One-sentence summary

With the historical peak week of hurricane season upon us, we take a look at what has happened so far, how seasonal forecasts have performed, and what we can glean for the rest of hurricane season based on the active start and El Niño.

How are those seasonal forecasts holding up?

Back in June when we launched The Eyewall, one of the things we did was dive into the components of the seasonal forecast. We explained that the 2023 hurricane season would be trickier than normal, as the developing El Niño, which typically reduces storm activity would be battling an outrageously warm Atlantic Ocean, a feature that would be good for busy storm activity. So far, that battle seems to be exactly what’s playing out. The “consensus” forecast was 16 named storms, 7 hurricanes, and 3 majors. As of Monday, we sat at 12 named storms, 3 hurricanes, and 2 majors.

Our accumulated cyclone energy for the season, or ACE, sits around 125 percent of normal for the first week of September.

As of yesterday, the Atlantic was running about 125 percent of normal activity, from an ACE standpoint. (Colorado State University)

If the season ended right now, we would be sitting in the upper tier of “below normal” seasons. In other words, we already have one heck of a base and seem to be on our way to (at worst) an average season. The seasonal forecasts did a good job telegraphing this, and frankly some of the more active seasonal forecasts that I believed were more out of an abundance of caution are the ones most likely to verify.

And this isn’t because of ticky-tack storms that last a day or two. Idalia, Don, and Franklin, the three hurricanes account for nearly 75 percent of the seasonal ACE to date. So three legitimate storms make up the majority of the total. Back in June we said that we believed the Caribbean would struggle (it mostly has), the eastern Atlantic would be busy (it’s been more the central Atlantic, so that point is a little fuzzier), and that the most concerning items this season would be systems forming close to home (Idalia counts for that). So thus far, this is going mostly as expected, if not a little bit busier. Kudos to the seasonal forecasters for not just going all-in on El Niño.

Where are we going?

Well, this week we are likely to see another big jump in seasonal ACE when Lee forms.

The likely track of future Lee should go north of the islands but may impact Bermuda. It’s going to be a very strong storm. (Tomer Burg)

From our morning post, you can read how we expect that to become a major hurricane, likely at least a category 4 storm. This will be a big ACE adder, and I suspect we’ll see things shoot up at least into the 70s once Lee is done, pushing us into the “average” tier of seasons if it ended right there. Behind Lee, we may get another storm in the eastern Atlantic, so there’s an opportunity for a few more ACE units.

But here’s something. If you look at the European ensemble model forecast for wind shear in days 11 to 15, which pushes us out to near September 20th now, you can see that the Gulf and western Atlantic are ripping with shear.

Wind shear is forecast to remain well above normal in the Gulf and western Atlantic for mid-month. (Tropical Tidbits)

If that happens as forecast, anything in the Gulf will struggle, as would anything coming out of the Caribbean. However, the lower wind shear in the eastern Atlantic and central Atlantic suggests these would be the areas where storms could continue to form, continuing the legacy of the 2023 season to date. We may see less hostile conditions return to the Gulf and western Atlantic in the final days of September, but that’s obviously a long way off.

What does El Niño tell us?

Quite frankly, if we assume that El Niño is up and humming now and the influence is strengthening, then we should expect to see a lot of what we’ve already seen for the remainder of hurricane season. Here is a map of all hurricanes in Septembers and Octobers since 1950 when the Oceanic Niño Index (ONI) was 1.0 or greater for June-July-August (this year’s value is 1.1).

Hurricane seasons most similar to this one in terms of El Niño produced a lot of central Atlantic storms in September and October and not a lot of serious land impacts. (NOAA)

With a couple notable exceptions, this map shows a lot of fish storms and middling systems in the western Atlantic. The two most notable exceptions were Joaquin in 2015 which killed 34 people (33 of whom were aboard the El Faro). And also Betsy in 1965, which killed 81 and inundated New Orleans. Emily in 1987 hit Hispaniola and Bermuda. And I think that sums up the season so far: A lot of middling storms and mostly fish storms with one potent hit in Idalia.

All in all, given what we see on the maps right now and given how this season has gone, there are two primary areas that probably should watch for land impacts: Bermuda and the Greater Antilles. If we can relax shear enough late in the season and get a disturbance in the Caribbean that comes straight north, you never know what you can get out of that, and those often threaten Cuba, Jamaica, Hispaniola or the Bahamas. Bermuda remains in the target line I think for at least one or two more storms. Lastly, the eastern Gulf or off the Southeast coast may be secondary areas to watch, given the warm waters and potential for just the right things coming together at the wrong time, sort of like what we saw with Idalia and to a far less impactful extent, Harold in Texas earlier this season.

Will it be enough to drive ACE above normal for the season in the end? I’m not certain, but it will be close.